Current:Home > MyNorth Dakota judge will decide whether to throw out a challenge to the state’s abortion ban -TradeStation
North Dakota judge will decide whether to throw out a challenge to the state’s abortion ban
View
Date:2025-04-15 23:34:33
BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — Attorneys argued Tuesday over whether a North Dakota judge should toss a lawsuit challenging the state’s abortion ban, with the state saying the plaintiffs’ case rests on hypotheticals, and the plaintiffs saying key issues remain to be resolved at a scheduled trial.
State District Judge Bruce Romanick said he will rule as quickly as he can, but he also asked the plaintiffs’ attorney what difference he would have at the court trial in August.
The Red River Women’s Clinic, which moved from Fargo to neighboring Moorhead, Minnesota, filed the lawsuit challenging the state’s now-repealed trigger ban soon after the fall of Roe v. Wade in 2022. The clinic was North Dakota’s sole abortion provider. In 2023, North Dakota’s Republican-controlled Legislature revised the state’s abortion laws amid the lawsuit. Soon afterward, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint, joined by doctors in obstetrics, gynecology and maternal-fetal medicine.
North Dakota outlaws abortion as a felony crime, with exceptions to prevent the mother’s death or a “serious health risk” to her, and in cases of rape or incest up to six weeks of pregnancy.
The plaintiffs allege the law violates the state constitution because it is unconstitutionally vague for doctors as to the exceptions, and that its health exception is too narrow.
The state wants the complaint dismissed. Special Assistant Attorney General Dan Gaustad said the plaintiffs want the law declared unconstitutional based upon hypotheticals, that the clinic now in Minnesota lacks legal standing and that a trial won’t help the judge.
“You’re not going to get any more information than what you’ve got now. It’s a legal question,” Gaustad told the judge.
The plaintiffs want the trial to proceed.
Meetra Mehdizadeh, a staff attorney with the Center for Reproductive Rights, said the trial would resolve factual disputes regarding how the law would apply in various pregnancy complications, “the extent to which the ban chills the provision of standard-of-care medical treatment,” and a necessity for exceptions for mental health and pregnancies with a fatal fetal diagnosis.
When asked by the judge about the trial, she said hearing testimony live from experts, as compared to reading their depositions, would give him the opportunity to probe their credibility and ask his own questions to clarify issues.
In an interview, she said laws such as North Dakota’s are causing confusion and hindering doctors when patients arrive in emergency medical situations.
“Nationally, we are seeing physicians feeling like they have to delay, either to run more tests or to consult with legal teams or to wait for patients to get sicker, and so they know if the patient qualifies under the ban,” Mehdizadeh said.
In January, the judge denied the plaintiffs’ request to temporarily block part of the law so doctors could provide abortions in health-saving scenarios without the potential of prosecution.
A recent state report said abortions in North Dakota last year dropped to a nonreportable level, meaning there were fewer than six abortions performed in 2023. The state reported 840 abortions in 2021, the year before the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling overturning Roe v. Wade.
The court’s decision enabled states to pass abortion bans by ending the nationwide right to abortion.
Most Republican-controlled states now have bans or restrictions in place. North Dakota is one of 14 enforcing a ban on abortion at all stages of pregnancy. Meanwhile, most Democratic-controlled states have adopted measures to protect abortion access.
The issue is a major one in this year’s elections: Abortion-related ballot measures will be before voters in at least six states. Since 2022, voters in all seven states where similar questions appeared have sided with abortion rights advocates.
___
Associated Press writer Geoff Mulvihill in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, contributed to this story.
veryGood! (281)
Related
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- What time the 2024 solar eclipse starts, reaches peak totality and ends today
- New Jersey officials drop appeal of judge’s order to redraw Democratic primary ballot
- Caitlin Clark forever changed college game — and more importantly view of women's sports
- Meta releases AI model to enhance Metaverse experience
- Boy trapped and killed after a truck crashes into river in Colorado, sheriff says
- More proof Tiger Woods is playing in 2024 Masters: He was practicing at Augusta
- Will the solar eclipse affect animals? Veterinarians share pet safety tips for the 2024 show
- This was the average Social Security benefit in 2004, and here's what it is now
- Trump campaign says it raised $50.5 million at Florida fundraiser
Ranking
- Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
- Ohio state lawmaker’s hostile behavior justified legislative punishments, report concludes
- Happy solar eclipse day! See photos as communities across US gather for rare event
- Tori Spelling Reveals If a Pig Really Led to Dean McDermott Divorce
- Pressure on a veteran and senator shows what’s next for those who oppose Trump
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Shapes Up
- Caitlin Clark, not unbeaten South Carolina, will be lasting memory of season
- Trump campaign says it raised $50.5 million at Florida fundraiser
Recommendation
B.A. Parker is learning the banjo
Trisha Yearwood pays tribute to June Carter Cash ahead of CMT Awards: 'She was a force'
Hall of Fame coach John Calipari makes stunning jump from Kentucky to Arkansas
Is it safe to look at a total solar eclipse? What to know about glasses, proper viewing
A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
Total solar eclipse 2024: Watch livestream of historic eclipse from path of totality
New Jersey officials drop appeal of judge’s order to redraw Democratic primary ballot
Lainey Wilson Reveals She Got Her Start Impersonating Miley Cyrus at Hannah Montana Parties